Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘ethics in cardiology’

PCI and coronary stents are revolutionary concepts , still , they may not be  great life saving devices  . . . though the collective cardiology wisdom may seem to suggest so !

stents-india

The ideal way to describe a stent could be “Its a metal coil , if inserted properly in certain population of severely obstructive forms coronary artery disease may save some lives in acute situations  or give relief to pain in non acute situations”

*While the true benefits for the patient population is unsure . . . it’s absolutely certain stents  confer highest  quality of life to the  manufacturers and their chain of associates including the Noble professionals !

sir-william-osler

I wonder , what would be his comment about ubiquitous stents that rule the current era !

Learnt cardiologist’s  will know the true life saving potential of these stents (In the way its been currently used ) Their conscience will also tell how Inappropriate and Indiscriminate usage of stents has possibly injured or consumed  more human lives , that may even beat the number of lives saved .(Oh, Its a wild, rude statement  friend!)

I sincerely believe the move by Government of India to control the stent price ( to enable all our countrymen to get it)  . . . as if  “stents are the only staple diet” for heart patients is ill-founded and dangerous .

What the Government may not be aware of  is  . . .This 45000 crore omnipresent stent  industry is playing havoc in the life of patients not only financially  but also biologically to harm their blood vessels.

It is near foolish to tackle the scourge of human beings -Atherosclerosis,   a diffuse medical disease with a lesion specific intervention .This is especially true when we want to tackle it in population based approach . Yes, some super rich and elite  get sophisticated stents thinking that they are privileged .Please understand  rich tend to suffer more  with technology. Often  times non affordability is also a bliss for the poor .(You can’t write any rubbish man !)

Who will tell this to our  policy makers ?

Never ape the private sector health care , states must have different priorities.There are Infinite number of studies that  very clearly reveal medical management and life style modification is the sure and successful way to tackle CAD.(I think I need not dwell into this as evidence is explicit .)

Meanwhile, let me give one example of  the futility of innovation and perils of premature release of half baked science .While one section of Industry is coming out with stents made up of exotic new metals , simultaneously other group is innovating and experimenting the exactly opposite , how to get rid of the metal ie bioreabsorable stents. Mind you, one of the latest generation stents was severely reprimanded in a Landmark trial ABSORB 2 and 3. Its a comical irony some of the hospitals and cardiologists  feel bad  to miss this red flagged stent that are taken out of their cath lab because of price cap. ( A pat for the Govt for this !)

Its a multi billion dollar Industry (Note : there is no pardon for Indian companies to exploit either !) trying to disseminate a commercially motivated concept intelligently including the stake holder Government in their loop. The move to liberalise stent usage is  most unfortunate thing  as the Govt has  inadvertently increased the risk of abuse .Let the new age Indian not be proud  about “Stent for all ” movement since the  Govt will ultimately  have to shell  out for this imperfect therapeutics through public insurance .

Final message 

Though capping the price of the stent by Government  do carry  some sense  . . . ultimately      I feel its a trap . It’s akin to let loose a dubious  modality in public domain within easy reach . Already the companies want to increase per capita metal consumption. That process will only get accelerated now.In a country where bulk of the ACS patients not even get prehospital Aspirin, we talk about primary PCI for all.It is a shocking medical economic hijack played in day light by a  new generation thrombolytic called TNK -TPA is able to jack up the cost of coronary care with  marginal benefits based on dubious off shore  studies. I guess , very shortly the thrombolytic  warrior Streptokinase is likely to be declared as  endangered  species and perilious  for STEMI patients.If Govt really wants  to tackle population based  emergency cardiac care they should first upgrade country wide taluk or municipal level  hospital with 24 h coronary care facility with trained doctors who can save more lives than the combined efforts of socially concerned  corporate care takers.

Some one should tell the Govt, cath labs would never come into the scheme of things for mangaing ACS in bulk of our country men.The Law makers and the corridors of power should be  “forced  to realise”  there is an urgent &  broader issue to be addressed.Its not only in cardiology but in all walks of health delivery system. How to prevent “contamination of  medical science by pseudo cost effective scientific interventions fueled by corporate greed ? They should start  sensitizing the young medical professionals in medical schools that will help the Noble profession remain Noble !

Read Full Post »

I was recently asked to suggest a topic for debate on STEMI in  a major Indian cardiology conference. I wished , this is what we  should be mulling  over, with a set of  virtual  guest lectures and special invitees from heaven ! Plenary  session : State of the Art  STEMI care             Time :  11.AMSpeaker : Dr Hippocrates Topic : Aren’t  we erring   on either side of the  Noble profession ? Moderator:  Dr. William Osler Chairperson :  Dr .Harvey Cushings, Dr,Sir Thomas Lewis ,Dr Paul Wood , Excerpts : “While , vast number of  our country-men’s  culprit artery doesn’t even get that  mandatory  Aspirin on time . . . an urban rich  man’s  distal non-culprit artery  is decorated with a fancy  bio-vascular scaffold making  that innocuous lesion vulnerable in the process as well !  Aren’t  we erring   on either side  in the  Noble profession ?

Read Full Post »

As I was mulling about  the misplaced  priorities  in modern health delivery  , today’s (25-01-2015) edition  of  “The Hindu” , India’s National newspaper carries an exact article by Dr B.M.Hegde .

No doubt  ,his articles are constantly criticized  by the scientific community for  the simple reason, he is forcibly  trying to add wisdom to science !

 

 

Read Full Post »

Your clock starts  now !

 

clock gif  dr s venkatesan002

Chronic stable angina : Most can be effectively managed  by  optimal /intensive medicines and life style Interventions .About 10% will require PCI/CABG.

ACS – STEMI:  Primarily  managed  with  rapid and competent  pre-hospital care with prompt thrombolysis in or out of hospital .Patients  with  large STEMI who develop complications (Again about 10 %)   require PCI and few additional  lives can be saved.

ACS-NSTEMI : This is  the group that demand  an  important role for PCI . All true high risk UA/NSTEMI patients  should receive urgent coronary  angiogram and critical lesions  should either be stented or  sent for CABG  (If the lesions are multiple and complex ) The field of interventional  cardiology  is  expected  to play a major  role in  this category of  patients for the simple reason , we  not only give dramatic  relief from angina and also prevent a  potentially a huge MI that is waiting to happen !

* It is vital to emphasise  the “Aim and  objective” in  NSTEMI  management  is critically different from other two. We know ,  in CSA   the aim is to give relief  symptoms  and improve excercise capacity . Both PCI/CABG  are  unlikely  to prevent a future MI in CSA..In STEMI it has already occurred .The aim is to salvage myocardium  and prevent  future events. While PCI can do the former , it can’t do the later . In STEMI scenerio ,we have very good  alternate  modality called thrombolysis which can easily beat the  pPCI  in , cost , availability and time  (and  hence efficiency as well  in  most  countries !)

Counter thought

The above suggestion  is too simplified ,generalized , misleading , and  unscientific, should   strongly be disagreed. For those people who disagree , I provide an alternate scheme  .It is ultra short ,comes in  5 lines .Very practical  and  scientific too  !

In any  patient , who is  suspected to have either  acute or chronic  coronary syndromes ,take them to the cath lab in an  urgent or semi urgent fashion .Do an angiogram and stent all lesions  that you feel important . If  stenting is not possible  manage  with optimal medicines and /or send them to the surgeons.

Final message

The essence of catheter based coronary care is simple.We complicate it. To understand this concept  100’s of cardiology  journals  and as many conferences and infinite  number of books are churned out every year !

 

 

 

 

Read Full Post »

Following are revered  facts  . . .  among the  “Guardians of   Cardiology” !

myths-truths-300x300

When false truths are synthesized to conceal a true myth . . . where will the poor myth complain ?Following are revered  facts  . . .  among the  “Guardians of   Cardiology” !

  • Primary PCI  is a greatest innovation  in modern day cardiology .Without this modality  most  STEMI patients will buy Instant  tickets to grave yard !
  • A cardiologist who intends to  thrombolyse  a STEMI is considered as a low quality cardiologist .
  • Streptokinase should have  no place in the crash carts of modern coronary care units.
  • There is nothing called “Time window” for rescue angioplasty.
  • VVI pacemaker  will convert an electrical problem of heart block into a mechanical one by depressing LV function .
  • Digoxin is an obsolete  drug even in well established cardiac failure with dilated heart.
  • Beta blockers not only fail to control  blood pressure smoothly , it often converts  a hypertensive individual into a unhealthy one  by it’s prohibitive side effects !

 

Read Full Post »

CAD is growing as an epidemic in most  parts of the globe. It  is  a major determinant of health status of any country .Great strides in diagnostic, treatment modalities of CAD  have been made in the last few decades. Still , the core principle of management of CAD resides in simple things like  risk factor reduction / optimization , life style changes and few essential cardio-protective medications  Aspirin, beta blockers and statins.

However , modern scientists have made a  firm statement that  knowing the coronary anatomy before starting the treatment is the only scientific approach . It is a huge assumption !

Is it practical ? or is it really required ?

CAD can be managed  by  means of medicines  ,  interventions or surgery. Revascularisation is required  only for  those , who have  critical , symptomatic lesions.

It is estimated , in only  a fraction of CAD patients ,  we would require to know the anatomy . We have set criteria to choose  patients  for CAG , who are  likely to have critical lesions.Physicians  are trained for that elusive wisdom to choose  such patients .Standard text books do mention clear-cut Indications for doing  CAGs. Unfortunately , it is  least respected and followed .

Cardiac physicians who  would boast  they  can’t treat a CAD without knowing  the coronary anatomy  are clinically handicapped  or poorly trained.

I am afraid such a class of  cardiologists are rapidly breeding in the country side. They are  encouraged to attend  CME on clinical  cardiology and basic principles of  clinical decision-making  .

We can’t  keep  on doing CAGs like ECG for every episode of  angina . In fact treating CAD without knowing  the anatomy remains (And it should  be ) the dominant theme contemporary  clinical practice . CAG is multi -edged sword

The most important side effect of routine  coronary angiogram  is , it  ends up in infinite number of inappropriate interventions ! 

I think , we should pray in Hippocratic  temples for sufficient wisdom  to choose our patients. We can also learn it from Neurologists , they  somehow  manage most  forms of cerebrovascular  diseases (scientifically too ! )  without asking  for angiogram of  circle of Willis !  Mind you. . . brain is equally a vital organ !

Final message

It needn’t be a crime to treat  CAD*  without knowing the coronary anatomy. Rather  . . . it would be so  , to ask for CAG indiscriminately  , in every episode of chest pain , without applying clinical sense !

* Emergencies included.

Read Full Post »

The current  fad called EBM has lots of lacunae. Though evidence based approach is  considered  the ultimate  journey  towards  truth  ,lot of non academic factors contaminate it .In it’s  current form , it is difficult to comprehend it.

This is an attempt to decode the mystery of EBM  expressed in a simplified  lay person’s term .They are the ones  from whom we learn  medicine. They are our teachers in the true sense.

evidence based cardiology guidelines evidecne levelBy the way ,it  is also my approach  to   EBM .Sorry , if  this post  sounds  arrogant ! It is not the intention .Truths often times appear brutal .

And   . . . the  Genius  approach to EBM  for comparison

 

2011_AHA_Classification

 

 

 

Read Full Post »

Older Posts »